The Wallflower by J.L. Beck

Britt's take

I’m going straight for the red-flag hero. This is a college dark romance with a secret society, a morally questionable love interest, and the kind of tension that makes you question your own judgment a little. This was a wild ride from start to finish—the last 10% had my jaw on the floor. It’s the first book in a duology, and fair warning: the cliffhanger ending had me immediately picking up book two. If Drew works for you, just wait until you meet his friends.